11/8/10, 11:10 AM

Rank these Eagles moments.

(4 voters, 6 abstainers)

1st

4th and 26 (2003)

2nd

Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)

3rd

Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)

4th

Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)

5th(tie)

Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
A:
4th and 26 (2003)
B:
Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)
C:
Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)
D:
Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)
E:
Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
F:
Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
  • 1 ballot
    A
    B
    D
    C
    E
    F
    1st
    4th and 26 (2003)
    2nd
    Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)
    3rd
    Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)
    4th
    Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)
    5th
    Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
    6th
    Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
    danburd
  • 1 ballot
    A
    C
    B
    E
    F
    D
    1st
    4th and 26 (2003)
    2nd
    Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)
    3rd
    Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)
    4th
    Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
    5th
    Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
    6th
    Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)
    piffle21
  • 1 ballot
    B
    D
    A
    C
    F
    E
    1st
    Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)
    2nd
    Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)
    3rd
    4th and 26 (2003)
    4th
    Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)
    5th
    Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
    6th
    Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
    slifty
  • 1 ballot
    C
    A
    F
    D
    E
    B
    1st
    Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)
    2nd
    4th and 26 (2003)
    3rd
    Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
    4th
    Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)
    5th
    Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
    6th
    Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)
    erek
  • 6 ballots
    [
    A
    B
    C
    D
    E
    F
    ]
    --
    4th and 26 (2003)
    --
    Blocking a field goal and returning it for a touchdown (2005)
    --
    Clinching a Super Bowl birth against Atlanta (2004)
    --
    Beating the Cowboys with T.O. in his first game against Philly (2006)
    --
    Coming to within three points of beating the future 16-0 Patriots, on the road, with a backup QB (2007)
    --
    Crushing the Cowboys in the final week of the regular season to clinch an improbable playoff berth (2008)
    el_Duffel_GOAT lyla MrNonchalant Shade TheKindDictator TheOneTaterToRuleThemAll
1
2
3
4
5
5
  • 1)
    4th and...
  • 2)
    Blockin...
  • 3)
    Clinchi...
  • 4)
    Beating...
  • 5)
    Coming ...
  • 5)
    Crushin...
- 3 0.75 3 0.75 3 0.75 4 1 4 1
1 0.25 - 2 0.5 3 0.75 3 0.75 3 0.75
1 0.25 2 0.5 - 2 0.5 4 1 4 1
1 0.25 1 0.25 2 0.5 - 3 0.75 2 0.5
0 0 1 0.25 0 0 1 0.25 - 2 0.5
0 0 1 0.25 0 0 2 0.5 2 0.5 -
5 Comments
danburd
11/9/10, 9:50 AM
hmm... that should be Super Bowl "berth," not "birth"
 
erek
11/9/10, 10:52 AM
This was actually my favorite Eagles moment
 
danburd
12/19/10, 12:58 PM
(edited 12/19/10, 1:52 PM)
I'd like to submit the last play of today's game as an addition to this poll... I think I'd put it second only to 4th and 26 but only because that was a playoff game.
5 post branch
quetzal
12/23/10, 3:59 AM
(edited 12/23/10, 4:00 AM)
people are remembering the punt return more than anything, around philly talking about the specific play is the conversation starter, and literally everyone is talking about it. my coworkers, the janitors, the food truck people, people on the street describing themselves jumping up and down --at that play, not for 7 minutes. i think that, had the eagles only tied it, and had won in ot with a fg or td, the punt return would have still been the most memorable. yes it was the cap to a great comeback but the cap completely overshadows the comeback, as amazing as many of the plays (high gain vick runs, onside recovery), in that comeback were. walkoff punt returns are just that awesome...

also i guess you have to include the first 3 quarters too, piffle, which setup a comeback situation..
 
quetzal
12/23/10, 4:01 AM
also this isn't quite as elite but donovan's dallas scramble
2 post branch
page created in 0.71047806739807s